Thursday, September 28, 2023

Jersey Cat Fight


Will Townsend tear up the Tigers again?


Columbia Lions (1-1) at Princeton Tigers (1-1)

September 29, 2023

Kickoff Time: 7:00pm


Game Time Weather Forecast: 61 degrees and raining 

The Line: Columbia is a seven point underdog

TV/Radio: The game will be nationally televised on ESPNU with my old WVII-TV co-worker Eric Frede doing play-by-play and Jack Ford on color commentary. An audio-only feed with Lance Medow doing play-by-play and Shawn Fitzgerald '80 will be avaiable on GoColumbiaLions.com. 




Leading Story Lines

1) Both teams come into the game with a lot of unanswered questions after mixed performances in their first two games. No matter how ugly a win it might or valiant a loss, the winner of this game will likely be tabbed as an Ivy title contender and the loser will be seen as a spoiler at best. 

2) The status of a number of key players remains a total mystery because of some injuries and the "Non-information pact of the Ivies." Much of the game will be a lot different if Princeton OL Jalen Travis is out and if Columbia WR Bryson Canty remains on the sidelines. Oh and don't bother looking in the Princeton game notes for a starting lineup, they don't even bother to include one... though maybe omitting it is better than the outright falsehoods most Ivy game note starting lineups often are. 

3) This is an important game for Columbia interim Head Coach Mark Fabish for all the obvious reasons, but there's added importance for the New Jersey native who is clearly trying to increase Columbia's recruiting appeal in the Garden State. Of course, both Princeton and Columbia recruit nationally but the Lions would like to start challenging the Tigers more for some of Jersey's best high schoolers. 

3 Columbia Players to watch

-DE Justin Townsend #36 had a dominant three-sack game against Princeton last year, and he's one of those Jersey natives who chose Columbia. If Travis is out of the game, Townsend will be a bigger handful for the Tigers to handle. If Travis does play, it will be a great battle in the trenches. 

-WR JJ Jenkins #8 will likely play a major role in the game whether Canty is in the lineup or not. If Canty is out, Jenkins becomes CU's primary deep threat. If Canty does play, Jenkins could take major advantage of the extra attention going Canty's way. 

-LB CJ Brown #0 will be a major part of the Lion hopes to shut down the Princeton sideline screens and the running of RB John Volker. Brown will need his speed to get to key spots in time to disrupt the Tiger attack. 

3 Princeton Players to Watch

-QB Blake Stenstrom #18 is a very good passer and can even run pretty well when needed, (watch for the Tigers to run him on purpose to cross up the Columbia defense early). He's especially patient in the pocket, but without Travis anchoring the O-line to protect him late in the game against Bryant last Saturday Stenstrom was under too much pressure to do much damage. 

-DE Bakari Edwards #93 is a good pass rusher and a new face among the Tiger starters as a sophomore. With most of the focus on Princeton's excellent linebacking crew, he can make a difference up front. 

-P Brady Clark #89 has a good leg but had a terrible time handling wet footballs against Bryant, fumbling two of them away (with one luckily called back on a penalty). If we get the rain that's expected to come Friday night, he will have to prove he's learned something over the last five days. 

The Princeton Proving Ground

 


Princeton's old Palmer Stadium was pretty, but started to fall into disrepair



Columbia's annual game against Princeton has almost always been a major bellwether for the season at large... and that's been true for most of the last 100 years, not just since the official formation and start of Ivy League play in 1956.

You didn't know 2017 was going to be a special year until the Lions pulled out that dramatic 28-24 win on national TV at Princeton Stadium. And you knew Columbia probably wasn't championship material after losing to the Tigers every year since.

So many of Columbia's highest highs and lowest lows have come in games against their closest Ivy neighbors to the south. The 1933 CU team that went on the win the Rose Bowl on New Year's Day 1934 had one loss. You guessed it, it was to Princeton. The 1961 Ivy championship team's one conference loss was to Princeton. The 1988 game that end Columbia's then-record 44-game losing streak? Yep, it was a win over Princeton.

Last year, the Lions were exposed a bit in a 24-6 loss at home to the Tigers; a defeat that makes more sense now that we know then-starting QB Joe Green was suffering from a shoulder injury. But his injuries aside, Columbia committed some of its biggest blunders of the years in the contest and continued that sloppier play at crucial times until thankfully turning it around in week eight at Harvard and through the rest of the season. 

Of course, the first Ivy game of the year would be super crucial whether it was against Princeton or not. But there's something about playing the Tigers that seems to test this program more than anyone else. Perhaps it's because Princeton is a school that is so different in setting and character from the urban Columbia landscape. Perhaps it's the proximity the two campuses share. 

This year, Lion fans hope there is truth to a impression many Ivy experts have that this is a rebuilding year of sorts for the Tigers while Columbia is ready to roar a little louder .

Wednesday, September 27, 2023

Week 3 Picks

 


I have a rough time of it in week 2, going 3-4 straight up and 3-4 against the spread. My season totals are now 13-7 SU and 10-9-1 AGS


Penn -3 vs. Dartmouth

This spread seems exactly right for a Penn team that appears to have most of the ingredients needed to win a title and a Dartmouth team that is improving quickly. Both defenses are very strong, and this could end up being a 17-13 affair or something like that. 


Holy Cross -10 vs. Harvard

The Crimson's competition has been getting tougher each week, and now they take to the road for the first time in 2023 against a program that always loves to thrash them. 


Yale -13 1/2 vs. Morgan State

If the Elis can't cover this spread against Morgan State at home (well, Yale is ALWAYS at home) then I think it's fair to say this team is in some form of crisis. 


Brown -11 1/2 vs. Central Connecticut

The Bears are going to look like a much better team at home, and they haven't looked that bad on the road so far anyway this season. 


Cornell -7 1/2 vs. Colgate

Cornell is looking really good. Colgate is not. 


Lafayette -14 vs. Bucknell

The Leopards get another home game here... and they will cover. 


Fordham -14 1/2 at Georgetown

Now, the wheels will start coming off for the Hoyas. 


Stetson -2 1/2 at Marist

I'm still not sold on the Red Foxes, despite their OT win at Valpo last Saturday. 

Tuesday, September 26, 2023

Tall Order/Short Week


As expected, Princeton has a new star on the D-line: Bakari Edwards

The Lions face the usual big test pressure and excitement that comes every year with its first Ivy game of the season vs. Princeton. But adding to the excitement is the national TV spotlight coming from the ESPNU airing of the game Friday night. 

It's also a short week with that kickoff coming about 18 hours earlier than a usual Saturday afternoon contest. So there's less time for the team, and those of us covering the game, to prepare. 

Let's start by looking at Princeton and how the Tigers have fared so far...

As I noted in my league-wide preview, Princeton came into this season with the best pocket passer in the league in QB Blake Stenstrom, but also faced major challenges from the graduations and transfer departures of many of its best players from 2021 and 2022. 

So far, that concern has proven to be legitimate. The Tigers are 1-1 on the backs of an easy, but not dominating, win over U. San Diego and a surprise loss at home to Bryant. 

Without many of the experienced O-lineman he had protecting him and at least two world class receivers to throw to last year, Stenstrom's stats through the first two games are way down from this point in 2022. 

This season, Stenstrom is averaging just 175 yards passing per game, with two TDs and two INTs on a 57% completion rate. Last year after two games, Princeton was 2-0, and Stenstrom was averaging 274 passing yards per game, with three TDs and two INTs and a 72% completion rate. 

The difference is even more stark when you look at the receiving stats. This year the top Princeton receiver, Luke Colella, has a total of nine catches for 96 yards and one TD. Last year after two games, current Cincinnati Bengal Andrei Iosivas had 13 catches for 199 yards and 3 TD's, and his fellow All Ivy WR Dylan Classi had 10 catches for 132 yards. 

Now there is an added concern for the Tiger offense as the already graduation-gutted offensive line may be without its best remaining player in Jalen Travis, who had to be helped off the field near the end of the Bryant loss. Many consider Travis to be an NFL draft prospect. The breakdown in pass coverage for Stenstrom after Travis left the game was noitceable. In fact, the entire offense sputtered after that. 

On the bright side for Princeton, RB John Volker has come back from 2022's injury with a vengeance. He has a total of 240 yards so far this season and a hefty 7.1 yards per carry average and two TDs. It's been a long time since the Tigers offense featured a single primary running back as its key weapon. In the Bob Surace era, Princeton has usually been mostly pass oriented, with the running load split between a number of backs and the QB. Friday night's game will likely give us an answer as to whether the Tigers will shift down a gear or two when it comes to passing. 

The Princeton defense is performing well, considering it also suffered a lot of graduation losses on the D-line and in the secondary. So far, the Tigers have allowed a total of just 403 total yards and 28 total points. That's compared to last season when Princeton had already given up 496 yards and 31 points. This year's Tigers are also allowing just 1.2 yards per rushing carry. 

As expected, your leading Princeton tacklers all come from its very deep and talented linebacking crew. They are senior Ozzie Nicholas, senior Will Perez, and senior and 2022 co-Defensive Bushnell Cup Winner Liam Johnson.

But a new ingredient in the defensive mix is sophomore edge rusher Bakari Edwards, who already has three sacks and a safety on the young season. 

While Tiger fans are griping about special teams problems because of a failed PAT and a costly fumbled punt snap in the loss to Bryant, there still is good experience and talent in this unit for Princeton. Junior PK Jeffrey Sexton is back after a stellar 2022 season, though he did miss that PAT* and has yet to attempt a FG this year. 

(*for some reason, the Princeton stat page has decided to completely erase PATs as a stat and just put an empty set parentheses to "indicate" the failed PAT in the Bryant game box score. I'm not sure if this is just a coding error or an Pravda-like effort to whitewash mistakes). 

New punter freshman Brady Clark has been doing fine replacing long-time Tiger punter Will Powers, (and I mean long time... it feels like Powers was at Princeton since the 1970s), with a 42-yard average and five boots inside the 20. The problem for the Tigers is that Clark has been busy; he's already punted 12 times compared to just six punts at this point last year for Powers. He was unable to handle two slippery balls against Bryant and fumbled both of them away, but the first fumble was called back on a penalty. 

But stats, as usual, really don't tell the whole story. We've been used to seeing Princeton dominate for most of the last 10 seasons, especially at this point in the season. Even in 2017, when the Tigers were forced to play without all-world QB John Lovett, Princeton still started 2-0 and boasted a very potent offense all year long. It's especially unusual to see the Tigers struggle in the passing game, or at least not put up huge numbers. So many of Princeton's passes have been little sideline jobs, with fewer shots down the field. 

And while it may be tempting to write off the Tiger loss to Bryant Saturday and blame it on the weather. It's important to note that Bryant came into the game without its two top running backs and still had decent success on the ground at times and took care of the ball. Rain or shine, I think the Tigers teams of the last two seasons would have easily beaten Bryant. 

I'm sure none of this is giving Columbia's coaches and players any false sense of superiority, but it should give them a good degree of optimism that this could be the year the Lions break a four-game losing streak to PU. 

From Princeton's point of view, there will be some pressure on the program to right the ship quickly and decisively vs. CU. That could mean that with everyone in the stadium expecting the Tigers to establish Volker's running attack early, Princeton may choose to test the Lion secondary early and often instead. 

Accurate or even remotely accurate injury reporting in the Ivy League is a lost cause, (as evidenced by Columbia WR Bryson Canty being introduced on the video board just prior to kickoff last Saturday as a starter when he wasn't starting and didn't even play... his appearance on the two-deep as the starting WR was also an example of how reliable game notes are), but if we find out Princeton OL Jalen Travis is indeed out of the game, it may change a lot of strategies on both sides. For what it's worth, I believe Canty will play and likely start Friday night, and that Lion QB Caden Bell is okay after almost getting his Bell rung, (sorry had to do that), late in the Georgetown game. Make sure to stay tuned for more non-information on injuries etc. from both the Princeton and Columbia athletic departments. 

Monday, September 25, 2023

Ivy Power Rankings

 



1) Penn

The Quaker defense has been better than its already good reviews coming into the season, while QB Aydin Sayin is still playing at a high level.

2) Cornell

While QB Jameson Wang is playing very well, it's the Big Red defense that has been making the difference so far.

3) Harvard

The Crimson are using a strong ground attack not many expected to see. If the defense improves from here, Harvard can be dangerous. 

4) Dartmouth

A respectable loss at UNH and a strong win at home over Lehigh have the Big Green more optimistic right now. 

5) Princeton

The Tigers didn't look too impressive in their win over USD, and then the offense and special teams floundered vs. Bryant on Saturday. 

6) Yale 

Yale's loss to Cornell was a close one, but if you watched the whole contest you saw that the Big Red really outplayed the Elis convincingly. Biggest surprise: Yale's vaunted O-line is underperforming. But the talent here is still too good to write them off. 

7) Columbia

The Lions looked solid in every phase of the game vs. Georgetown, and the week one loss to Lafayette is looking less embarrassing all the time given the Leopards' overall play. But one big win over a weak program isn't enough to take the question marks off this team yet.

8) Brown

Once again, the Bears have an offense that is excellent and a defense that breaks its fans' hearts time after time. But there's no team Brown can't theoretically beat on any given day.