Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Looking to Monmouth


Come on... papa needs a win against the Hawks!



Leading Off: A Big One

So on a scale of 1-10, how much do you think the Lions need a win in their home opener this Saturday?

After the devastation of the rout at Fordham and the horrifying bad luck injuries that went along with it, only a win can soothe the hurting CU nation at this point.

I get the argument that winning the following week at Princeton is even more important, but Columbia needs a win and needs it now.


Two Deeps

The latest round of two deeps should be released tomorrow.

As I expected last week, the week one two deeps were only about 80% accurate. Freshman Justin Aimonetti was the starting center and Ryan Thomas the backup, not the other way aroung.  Alan Watson was the backup RB, not Cameron Molina. WR Chris Connors was listed as one of the backups, but he was nowhere to be found on the sidelines.

Again, just always take the two deeps with a grain of salt.


Protection is Job 1

I’ll never understand how Columbia could snag a golden boy QB transfer from Stanford and then have the coaching staff send him out there with a pass-happy game plan and not enough decent protection against a bigger team like Fordham.

But let’s move on and see if the staff learns from its mistakes.

Not only does the Lion OL need to do a better job protection new starter Trevor McDonagh, but the game plan needs to get better and smarter to put our thinning QB corps less in harm’s way. The good news is that Monmouth’s defense isn’t nearly as big or aggressive as Fordham’s. The Hawks did get three sacks last week at Holy Cross, but Monmouth played with a big lead for much of that game and could afford to blitz more.

I thought every time Marcorus Garrett touched the ball Saturday it felt electric. He ran extremely well, and with very good instincts. The few times he stayed in the backfield to help protect Nottingham his pass blocking was clearly much improved. Garrett is a star and a team captain. As much as the team should rally around McDonagh, this is Garrett’s turn to really play a leadership role. I wonder if he, or any other player, is even allowed to approach the coaches and ask for more of a role. Let’s hope so.

This should also be an important game for TE Hamilton Garner, who was shut down for the most part against Fordham. He could play a big role in helping McDonagh feel more comfortable as the game begins.

But it all comes back to the O-line in the end. I’m actually for giving them a bit of a pass for Fordham considering how much bigger, stronger, and blitz-happy the Rams were. But while Monmouth is a very good opponent, the Hawks defense is much closer to the Lions level. The front five needs to step up.


Hempel/Williams Share Player of the Week Honors


Harvard QB Connor Hempel and Dartmouth QB Dalyn Williams both had big games Saturday, but I’m not sure how they won the Ivy Offensive Player of the Week award over Yale’s Tyler Varga who carried the ball 39 times for well over 200 yards in the Elis win over Colgate. Throw in the fact that both Dartmouth and Harvard were heavy favorites and Yale was an underdog, and I think you have an even stronger argument for Varga. 

9 comments:

oldlion said...

Was Connors injured? He had a lot of drops on Saturday. Connors has sure hands. What is the story?

oldlion said...

Sorry, I meant to say we had a lot of drops on Saturday, not that Connors had a lot of drops.

Anonymous said...

An alternative to Garrett needed. He can't do it all, teams focus on him.

oldlion said...

Varga ran 39 times against Colgate. Yale didn't need an alternative.

InwoodTiger said...

Remember that the Monmouth game is free for anyone who can show proof of residency in Upper Manhattan... There will be a table handing out community tickets at the gate.

Anonymous said...

The Lions have already lost 2 starters, so anyone can be sidelined
and RBs take constant hits.

Anonymous said...

I can't remember a time in columbia football history where it feels like columbia football is just snake bitten. There is no question that mangurian's "smaller is better" philosophy is just plain wrong....Nottingham how do you feel about your offensive line? Seriously...this is a travesty that is solely on the responsibility of the head coach.

Anonymous said...

Conners was in on 1 play and seemed to hobble off

Anonymous said...

How can a game played by players, and coached by a staff of eight or so be "solely the responsibility of the head coach"? Or didn't you know that football is a team game, in both playing and coaching? Good thing you won't be on the field!